On October 28, a newly built hillside house at 16680 Charmel Lane sold for $18.5 million. The Palisadian-Post reported it as the most expensive residential sale ever recorded in Marquez Knolls. The house was completed in 2024 and has more than 9,200 square feet. It listed at $21.7 million in July, so it closed about 15 percent below its first asking price, at roughly $2,000 a square foot.
For a buyer, the sale is the most useful number of the fall. Almost two years after the January 2025 fire, the Palisades has had plenty of land sales and very few finished new homes to price them against. That is starting to change. The first few completed homes, priced on what they cost to build, are now setting a ceiling that land prices have to fit under.
The vote a week later
Six days after the Charmel closing, Proposition TE, listed by the City Clerk as the "Property Transfer Tax Exemption for Victims of the January 2025 Fire Disaster," was on the November 3 city ballot. In the Los Angeles County Registrar's count posted November 13, it was passing with 658,230 yes votes, or 60.9 percent, to 422,682 no votes.
In The Real Deal's November 6 report on the vote, Carolwood Estates agent Nichole Shanfeld counted 566 Palisades transactions closed since the fire. She said she didn't expect the measure to "materially change anything" for the wider Palisades market. For a buyer pricing a house or a lot this winter, the comparison that matters is a finished home against a lot plus a build.
The arithmetic on a lot
In September, Compass agent Ryan Jancula told The Real Deal that the cheapest lot in a "good area" of the Palisades costs around $1.5 million. A buyer then spends another $3.5 million to $4 million to build, on top of the time construction takes. Before any delay, that puts the all-in cost of a new house on an entry lot at about $5 million to $5.5 million.
Two weeks later, the New York Post reported two finished new homes in the burn scar coming to market below that range. 744 Iliff Street, in the Alphabet Streets, is asking $4.99 million, and 605 Erskine Drive is asking $4.29 million. A spec house isn't an exact match for a custom build. Still, a buyer can compare both numbers. One is a finished house you can move into, with a known price. The other is a lot, a construction budget and a wait of unknown length, adding up to more.
That gap explains the most worrying number of the fall. The same Real Deal report said agents estimated that up to 40 percent of Palisades lot deals were falling apart in escrow, as buyers walked away before closing or couldn't agree with sellers on price. Jancula added that buyers from outside the Palisades were surprised by land prices and were calling to ask about $1 million lots in the Alphabet Streets that don't exist. Lot buyers walk when a finished house costs less than the plan they're signing up for.
Asking prices set by building costs
At the upper end, the first finished burn-scar listing is priced on what it costs to build. 837 Muskingum Avenue came to market at $13.99 million in early October, as one of the first new-construction homes in the burn scar, according to the New York Post. It's a spec home by Alison White Homes. The firm is building 14 homes in the Palisades, and the other 13 are for homeowners. Muskingum was finished first because its permits were in place before the fire.
Jancula told The Real Deal that he based the asking price on replacement cost. He said the price is at least 10 percent below what the property might have sold for before the fire, although the sellers would have preferred a pre-fire figure. Charmel Lane shows the same discipline from the buyer's side. A house finished in 2024, with ocean, city and mountain views, closed $3.2 million under its July asking price.
Prices are also coming down on new homes outside the burn scar. The same New York Post report said 1072 Amalfi Drive, still under construction, launched in April at $19.99 million and was cut to $17.99 million on September 24. 990 Corsica Drive first listed in April at $18.99 million and was asking $16.9 million by early October. At every price level, the finished homes on the market this fall have been priced on replacement cost or cut from their first asking price.
Lot prices have to come down to the finished homes
Before the first finished homes reached the market, lots traded with almost nothing to compare them to. The Real Deal reported several land sales above $5 million earlier this year: a lot on Glenhaven Drive at $6.6 million in February, one on Camarosa Drive at more than $7 million in March, and one on Antioch Street at $5.9 million in July. Those prices were set when hardly any finished new house had been listed. As a record of that period they hold up, but they no longer show where land is priced today.
Anthony Marguleas of Amalfi Estates told The Real Deal in September that his firm had sold nearly 70 Palisades lots since the fire. He estimated that a little over half of the burned lots had come on the market. That leaves a lot of land still unpriced, and the finished-home benchmarks are arriving just as it lists.
The Real Deal also described a sale that fell through after a long negotiation. Once the seller accepted, the buyer withdrew because "there was a cheaper closing around the corner," according to Beverly Hills Estates agent Jacqueline Chernov. Her advice to sellers afterward was that "if you have a good deal," they "should take it quickly." In a neighborhood with this few sales, one closing down the street can change a buyer's price.
The Alphabet Streets show this most clearly. Developers have been buying lots there because flat land is easy to build on and the numbers work against the expected sale price of the finished home, according to The Real Deal. Hillside view lots cost more and are harder to rebuild on. Builders there have to sell finished homes to make money, so they price land against finished-home prices. When 744 Iliff asks $4.99 million, that number sets the most a builder can pay for the next flat lot nearby.
What this means for a buyer this winter
A buyer choosing between a lot and a finished house can now do the math with real numbers on both sides. For a family that wants a specific floor plan, a specific view, or a builder they already trust, a lot can still be the right choice. The cost is roughly the $5 million to $5.5 million all-in figure on an entry lot, plus construction time, while a finished house down the street may ask less.
A buyer who wants to move in has more to work with than at any point since January 2025. There are list prices to compare, one major closing to measure against, and sellers whose own agents are pricing on replacement cost. Charmel Lane's 15 percent gap from list to sale also shows that a first asking price can come down.
Buyers who wait have a reason too. Each finished home that closes will make lot pricing clearer, and the Palisades will be setting prices for new construction one sale at a time for a while yet. Our earlier look at what buyers expect in Pacific Palisades new construction covers the layouts and finishes these benchmark homes will be judged on. Our piece on the bluff line that prices rebuilt homes explains why two lots on nearby streets can be valued very differently.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are new homes outside the burn scar holding their prices? Two of the larger ones have come down. 1072 Amalfi Drive went from $19.99 million to $17.99 million on September 24, and 990 Corsica Drive went from $18.99 million to $16.9 million, the New York Post reported on October 2.
Was 16680 Charmel Lane a rebuild? No. It was completed in 2024 and sold as new construction in Marquez Knolls. It's useful as a benchmark because it shows what the high end of the market paid for a finished, modern home in October 2026.
Are lots still selling above $5 million? They did earlier this year. Glenhaven Drive, Camarosa Drive and Antioch Street all traded above $5 million between February and July 2026. Newer land deals are being priced against finished homes that weren't on the market when those three closed.
If you're weighing a specific Palisades lot against a finished house, Susan Stark Homes will compare the two with the most recent closings on nearby streets. Request a Private Consultation before you write an offer on either one.